Table of Contents

Gone are the days when sales reps would flip through a telephone book and pick up the phone manually to reach prospects. In a world of caller IDs and insistence on taking appointments, it might seem like cold calling is dead. In fact, according to a study, cold calls are ineffective 69% of the time and have a significantly low conversion or win rate. 

So how, then, do modern businesses protect themselves to get new leads? 

The answer lies here - if you think about it, cold calling isn’t dead; the concept has developed into effective strategies that sales reps use to generate leads. 

If you’re wondering how to cold call for sales, we are here to help. 

So, our ultimate cold calling guide will be your comprehensive roadmap to mastering the nuances of this age-old yet ever-relevant sales approach.

What is Cold Calling?

Cold calling is your direct line to potential customers who have not explored your offering. It's the art of starting conversations from scratch and sparking interest with that initial outreach. 

Some folks dismiss cold calling as outdated. That's where the evolution comes into play. Modern cold calling isn't about cold, it's about smart. It's fueled by insights and tailored strategies that hit the mark. And that rejection fear? It's part of the game. Consider it a pivot point to refine your approach, not a roadblock.

Cold Calling vs Warm Calling 

Yes, there are two types of calls that sales reps make - cold calls and warm calls. What’s more effective when it comes to cold calling vs warm calling?

Pros of Cold Calling

  • Broad reach: Cold calling allows you to reach a large number of potential customers quickly.
  • New prospects: It helps target entirely new prospects who might not have been reached through other means.
  • Immediate feedback: Provides immediate feedback on the market response to your offering.

Cons of Cold Calling

  • Low conversion rates: Cold calling often has lower conversion rates as compared to warm calling.
  • Rejection: There's a higher chance of rejection since the prospect has no prior interest or connection with your business.
  • Time-consuming: It can be time-consuming and resource-intensive.

Warm Calling

Warm calling, on the other hand, involves reaching out to prospects who have shown some interest in your product or service. This interest might be expressed through actions like signing up for newsletters, downloading content, or engaging with your website. Warm calling implies that there is a level of familiarity or awareness about your business before the sales call is made.

Pros of Warm Calling

  • Higher conversion rates: Warm calling typically results in higher conversion rates because the prospect has already shown interest.
  • Established connection: There is an existing connection or awareness, making the conversation more receptive.
  • Focused approach: You can tailor your pitch based on the prospect's previous interactions with your business.

Cons of Warm Calling

  • Limited reach: The pool of warm leads is smaller compared to the broader audience reachable through cold calling.
  • Maintaining authenticity: There's a challenge in maintaining the conversation's authenticity if the prospect feels the interaction is scripted or insincere.

Cold Calling Strategies to Get Started

1. Researching target audience 

Doing your research before cold-calling is key to ensuring your approach is relevant and effective. Here is a checklist to help you gather the right information about your target audience:

  • Understand your ideal customer profile: Identify your prospect's pain points or characteristics.
  • Utilize company websites: Explore their website, social media, and blog for insight.
  • LinkedIn research: Research decision-makers backgrounds and connections.
  • News and industry publications: Follow industry news and trends for conversation starters.
  • Online communities and forums: Observe forums for audience discussions.
  • Case studies and success stories: Learn from case studies of similar companies.
  • Competitor analysis: Study competitor collaterals to help you identify gaps.
  • Google alerts: Monitor company updates and industry news.
  • Networking events and conferences: Attend events to engage directly and learn.
  • Ask questions during the call: Learn to understand their needs during calls.

2. Developing a cold call script 

Developing an effective cold call script requires careful planning and a customer-centric approach. Here is a framework to guide you through the process: 

1. Introduction

  • Start with a warm greeting and introduce yourself and your company.
  • Mention a commonality or connection if you have one, like a shared industry or a mutual contact.


Hi [Prospect's Name],

I'm [Your Name] at [Your Company]. Your expertise in [Specific Topic] impressed me. Let's connect to share insights on [Shared Interest].

2. Value proposition

  • Clearly state the value you offer. Address a specific pain point or challenge your prospect might be facing.
  • Explain how your product or service can provide a solution or benefit.

3. Engagement question

Ask an open-ended question to engage the prospect. This shows your interest in their needs. For say, you can ask, “Can you tell me more about your current approach to [relevant pain point]?”

4. Qualification

  • Gather information to determine if the prospect fits your solution well.
  • Ask about their role, challenges, goals, and decision-making process.

5. Customized pitch

  • Tailor your pitch based on the information you've gathered. Focus on what matters most to the prospect.
  • Use examples or success stories that resonate with their industry or pain points.

6. Handle objections

Anticipate common objections and prepare concise responses that address their concerns. For example, if there's an objection regarding budget, you could use, “Our solution often helps companies save costs in [relevant area]”

7. Call to Action

Guide the conversation toward a clear next step. This could be a meeting, demo, or further information. Make the action sound beneficial, such as, “Would you like to explore how our solution can streamline your [specific process]?”

8. Wrap-up

  • Thank the prospect for their time and consideration.
  • Offer your contact information, and be ready to answer any additional questions.

9. Note-taking and follow-up

  • During the call, note the prospect's responses and any follow-up actions.
  • If the prospect is interested but still deciding whether to commit, schedule a follow-up call or send relevant materials.

SUGGESTED READING: 14-Step Cold Calling Checklist

3. Crafting a compelling value proposition 

Crafting a compelling value proposition is at the heart of effective communication in sales. It's the art of distilling your offering into a concise, impactful message that resonates with your target audience. Here are a few tips for writing compelling value propositions:

  • Audience understanding: Know your audience deeply, understanding their needs.
  • Uniqueness and differentiation: Highlight what makes you stand out from competitors.
  • Clarity and simplicity: Be clear and concise, and use simple language.
  • Emotion and logic: Combine emotional appeal with logical reasoning.
  • Evidential support: Provide proof through testimonials, data, or examples.
  • Benefit quantification: Quantify the benefits for added impact.
  • Continuous improvement: Regularly refine your proposition based on feedback.

4. Anticipating objections 

Anticipating sales objections and effectively addressing them is a crucial skill. It shows your understanding of your prospect's concerns and positions you as a problem solver. 

Here's how to proactively handle objections:

  • Know common objections - Understand industry trends.
  • Preemptive addressing - Tackle concerns early.
  • Empathize and listen - Show understanding.
  • Provide solutions - Focus on solving, not arguing.
  • Use proof - Share success stories.  
  • Offer evidence - Back up claims with data.
  • Customize responses - Tailor to objections and situations.
  • Highlight benefits - Shift focus to the value gained.
  • Flexible approach - Provide alternatives when needed.
  • Confirm resolution - Ensure objections are addressed.

5. Setting clear goals 

Setting clear goals while cold-calling is fundamental to achieving success and maximizing your efforts. Here's why and how to set clear goals for your cold-calling activities:

  • Specific objectives: Define what you want from each call.
  • Alignment with strategy: Ensure goals match your sales strategy.
  • Quantify goals: Attach measurable metrics.
  • Realistic targets: Set achievable goals.
  • Timeframe: Add a timeframe for urgency.
  • Adapt and learn: Evaluate progress and adjust.
  • Celebrate achievements: Acknowledge even small wins.
  • Stay persistent: Goals keep you motivated amid challenges.

Do subscribe to Outplay’s Call of Fame, the widest library of cold call recordings to help you succeed with your cold calling.

The Cold Calling Process

1. Initial contact 

  • Building rapport: Begin with a warm and friendly tone. Engage in a short conversation about a common interest or connection.
  • Introduction: Introduce yourself and your company. Mention any shared affiliations to establish a connection.
  • Purpose of the call: Clearly state your value and how it relates to their needs.

Example: "Hello [Prospect's Name], I'm [Your Name] from [Your Company]. I saw that we both attended [Event], and I thought our [Solution] might help [Prospect's Company] enhance [specific pain point]."

2. Engagement and qualification 

  • Ask open-ended questions: Encourage prospects to share their challenges and goals. Listen actively to gather valuable information.
  • Qualify prospects: Determine if they align with your ideal customer profile and if your solution fits their needs.

Example: "Can you tell me more about your current process for [specific pain point]? I'd love to understand how our solution could assist."

3. Value proposition and benefits

  • Present your solution: Address their pain points directly and explain how your product or service solves their challenges.
  • Emphasize benefits: Highlight tangible outcomes and improvements they can expect from using your solution.

Example: "Our software streamlines inventory management, reducing errors and saving your team several hours weekly."

4. Handling objections

  • Empathize with concerns: Show understanding and empathy toward objections raised by the prospect.
  • Address objections confidently: Provide solutions or explanations that alleviate their concerns.

Example: If they express concerns about implementation difficulties, you could respond, “I completely understand your concerns. Many clients felt the same initially, but they found our team provides comprehensive support to ensure a smooth transition.”

Want some cold call inspiration?

Get a whole library of real-life cold calls that booked meetings

5.  Closing the call 

  • Gauge interest: Use open-ended questions to assess their engagement level and receptiveness to your solution.
  • Trial close: Propose a specific next step, such as arranging a demo or further discussion.

Example: "Based on our conversation, exploring a demo could provide valuable insights. What's your availability like next week?"

6. Set follow-up expectations 

  • Clearly define next steps: Ensure both you and the prospect understand the next actions to be taken.

Example: “I'll send you an email summarizing our conversation and include a link to schedule a demo. Does that work for you?”


Check out Outplay’s Cold Call Battle, a live simulation of a cold call.

Screenshot 2023-08-15 at 5.40.09 PM.png

Cold Calling Best Practices

1. Time your calls strategically

Avoid inconvenient times and days when prospects are likely to be busy.

Example: Aim for mid-morning or early afternoon when most people are available.

2. Practice empathy

Put yourself in the prospect's shoes to better understand their perspective.

Example: "I know your time is valuable, and I appreciate you taking a moment to discuss this."

3. Keep it concise

Respect their time by delivering a concise message that gets to the point.

Example: "I want to be mindful of your time, so I'll keep this brief."

4. Focus on benefits, not features

Communicate how your solution directly addresses their pain points.

Example: "Our software's real-time reporting can significantly alleviate the challenges you mentioned earlier."

5. Take notes

Document important details from the call for future interactions and reference.

Example: "Let me jot down your insights about integrating our solution with your current systems."

6. Personalize your approach

Mention specific details you've gathered from your research to demonstrate relevance.

Example: “I noticed your recent blog post about [topic], which aligns well with how our solution can assist.”

Common Mistakes to Avoid on Cold Calling

Of course, sales are tough, and even with all the help to make cold calls perfectly, something’s always bound to go awry. But that’s alright. Here’s how to be smart about cold calling and avoid mistakes most sales reps make.

1. Don’t call based on a static list

While cold calling is a great way to reach prospects and improve outreach and presence, there’s a lot of rejection involved in randomly cold calling people, especially if that list has become static.

You need to spend some time weeding out the dormant contacts from your database so that your cold calling success rate is higher.

2. Don’t call without researching the prospect‍

If you fail to read up on the prospect or the business, that’s a failed cold call right there. Remember, you’re getting an opportunity to speak to a business and convert the cold call.

Before you take that chance, read up on not just your business but the prospect’s business as well. Understand their pain points and pre-empt where you can fit into their needs.


3. Don’t stick to the script‍

Most sales reps will tell you that every cold call, even though it starts similarly, ends differently. 

While it’s important to be prepared with a script that helps you introduce yourself to each prospect, it’s important to make the prospect feel that the call has been personalized to suit their needs and really listen to the challenges they are facing.

4. Don’t be too friendly‍

While it’s important to strike up a conversation with the prospect on the other end, it’s also important to maintain a certain level of professionalism on the cold call.

Use formal language and maintain a consistent tone with the prospect. Speak to them in a familiar but confident tone that conveys seriousness.

5. Don’t forget about your USP‍

When cold calling clients, sales reps can tend to get too wrapped up in the client’s needs, while it’s important to listen to your clients, it’s also important to remember why you’re calling them, what your objective is, and how you can get the message across.

To do this skillfully, it’s important for sales reps to know their product inside out. The minute a prospect talks about an issue, a sales rep should be able to find a way to stitch the product into the conversation, to solve the prospect’s issue. This will help establish trust not only with the product but also help the prospect gauge how well you know the business.

How to Overcome Cold Calling Rejections

Dealing with rejection in cold calling can be challenging, but it's an inevitable part of the process. Here are some strategies to help you overcome cold calling rejections and improve your approach:

1. Maintain a positive mindset

Rejections are a natural part of the sales process. Stay positive, believe in your product or service, and understand that each rejection brings you closer to a successful sale. Your attitude can influence the conversation and help you handle objections more effectively.

2. Learn and refine

Treat every rejection as a valuable learning opportunity. Analyze the rejection, identify patterns, and learn from the feedback. Continuously refine your pitch, objection-handling techniques, and overall approach based on these insights.

3. Address objections effectively

Anticipate objections and prepare well-thought-out responses. Acknowledge the objection, empathize with the prospect's concerns, and provide a tailored solution or compelling reason to reconsider. Turn objections into opportunities to demonstrate your expertise and understanding of the prospect's needs.

4. Build rapport

Establish a genuine connection with the prospect. Take the time to understand their business, challenges, and goals. Active listening, empathy, and authenticity can help build rapport and create a positive impression, even if the prospect decides not to purchase immediately.

5. Offer value

Focus on delivering value throughout the conversation. Clearly communicate the benefits and unique selling points of your offering. Tailor your pitch to highlight how your product or service can solve the prospect's specific problems or fulfill their needs. Offer relevant insights, case studies, or success stories that demonstrate the real value your solution provides.

6. Effective follow-ups

Don't view a rejection as a dead end. Develop a systematic follow-up strategy. Send personalized follow-up emails or materials that reinforce the value proposition. Stay engaged without being pushy, and be persistent in your efforts. Some prospects may convert after multiple follow-ups.

7. Continuous improvement

Regularly assess your cold calling techniques. Seek feedback from colleagues, managers, or mentors. Participate in sales training programs to enhance your skills. Embrace a growth mindset and be open to adapting your approach based on the feedback and results you receive.

8. Practice resilience

Develop resilience to bounce back from rejections quickly. Celebrate your successes, no matter how small, and focus on the progress you're making. Remember that rejection is not a reflection of your worth but rather an opportunity to learn and improve.

Measuring and Iterating Cold Calling Success

Cold calling is a dynamic process that thrives on measurement and refinement. By systematically tracking key metrics, analyzing results, and embracing continuous learning, you can optimize your approach and achieve higher levels of effectiveness.

1. Track key metrics

Efficient cold calling begins with clear metrics that provide insights into your performance. These metrics could include:

Call Volume

Monitor the number of calls made within a specific timeframe.

Conversion Rates

Calculate the percentage of calls that lead to desired outcomes, such as appointments or product demos.

Objections Faced

Record the objections encountered during calls.

Objections Overcome

Track objections successfully addressed and converted.

Appointment Setting Success

Measure your success rate in scheduling follow-up appointments.

 Here are some best practice metrics you should keep while setting up your call metrics. 

Cold Calling Stats

Read more about the 28+ cold calling statistics sales teams might not (but should) know in 2023 here. 

2. Analyze results

Careful analysis of collected data helps uncover patterns and trends that drive successful cold-calling strategies:

Identify High-Performing Approaches

Determine which aspects of your script, value proposition, or objection-handling techniques yield positive results.

Pinpoint Common Objections

Recognize objections frequently encountered and develop strategies to overcome them.

Assess Timing and Schedule

Analyze when your calls tend to be most effective based on positive outcomes.

3. Continuous learning

Cold calling is a learning process that demands ongoing education and adaptation:

Refine Your Script

Use insights to tailor your script, emphasizing what resonates with prospects and refining objection responses.

Experiment and Innovate

Test variations in your approach to discover what works best in different scenarios.

Seek Feedback

Collaborate with colleagues to gain fresh perspectives and new ideas.

Review Call Recordings

Listen to recorded calls to evaluate your communication style and areas for improvement.

Invest in Skill Development

Participate in training to refine your cold-calling techniques and enhance your effectiveness.

Measuring and iterating infuses your cold-calling strategy with adaptability and growth. By tracking metrics, analyzing outcomes, and staying committed to learning, you enhance your success and contribute to a dynamic and evolving approach that resonates effectively with your prospects.

Unlock Cold Calling Success with Outplay

Cold calling as a valuable skill is a transformative mindset shift that can propel your sales journey to new heights.  To become a successful cold caller, remember that the keys lie in consistent practice, unwavering dedication, and applying the insights offered in this guide. 

Okay, but having the right tool goes a long way in making cold calling resource-efficient and successful. Outplay’s next-gen sales engagement platform hosts a built-in dialer that is made for modern sales teams. It’s all you need to make calls and switch tools or tabs. 

The dialer helps you monitor, coach, and guide in real time to enable your reps to close machines. And the pièce de résistance? The AI Power Dialer is a feature that’ll help you power through your call lists, leave voicemails, and more without you lifting a finger. Think about how many more calls you can smash out in a day. 

The best part is that you can make cold calling a part of multi-channel sequences to build outreach cadences with the greatest success chance. Incorporate calls with emails, LinkedIn, and texting to reach your prospects exactly where they want to be reached. All within Outplay. It’s the only tool you need. 

Want to give it a whirl? Start your free trial today. Curious to find out more? Book a personalized demo and have our experts walk you through all the outcomes you can achieve with Outplay.  

The next-gen dialer for modern teams

Elevate cold calling and build multi-channel cadences with Outplay
Get cold calling tips delivered straight to your inbox.

Outplay will help you generate sales right from your inbox. Try our Gmail Chrome Extension for free.